The real estate market in Put-in-Bay Ohio has always been very limited because there is frankly not much real estate on South Bass Island! The island itself is only about 2×4 miles in size. Over the years, since DeRivera purchased the island, all the plots on the island have been purchase by one family or another. The property on the island is divided into residential and business zones and variances. Your best bet to find available real estate is to contact a certified real estate agent who knows Put-in-Bay from experience.

Island Club Real Estate

Featured Real Estate

Island Club Rentals – Call 216-898-9951 Looking for a piece of Put-in-Bay to call yours? Real Estate at the Island Club provides an attractive opportunity for those looking to acquire real estate on South Bass Island, Ohio. You can also read more on other properties that might pique your interest.... View More

Put-in-Bay Condos Real Estate

Feature Real Estate

Put-in-Bay Condos Looking to acquire and trust the newest property on Put-in-Bay? Then hire trust lawyers as they can help you out legally. Well, The Put-in-Bay Condos consist of dozens of waterfront and pool view units situated right on the shores of Lake Erie.  The surrounding area offers countless opportunities... View More

Bolte Real Estate

Featured Real Estate

Bolte Real Estate “Nobody Knows Island Real Estate As We Do” With her level of energy and motivation, Corky isn’t the type of individual to wait for something to happen—she goes out and makes it happen. Her spirited approach, thorough follow-through, and unsurpassed knowledge are deeply appreciated by her clients.... View More

Invest in Put-in-Bay real estate with any of our recommended real estate agents such as Coldwell Banker Howard Perry and Walston.

From hiking to caves, from beach jet-ski riding to exploring the historic site of the old Victory Hotel pool to the new Commodore Resort MIST pool, you will always find new adventures that will not disappoint.

Staycation Investment

With such a popular local and staycation following, the local knowledge displayed by these agents is one of the main advantages of working with them vs a generic agent. Each business is independently owned and operated by professionals who bring a wealth of expertise to the local South Bass Island real estate market. The quality of our Agents in the Lake Erie area is outstanding, they are not only highly experienced, but they are also your neighbors so they want you to be happy with your purchase.

Whether you are looking to retire, invest, or live in Put-in-Bay, let one of our agents assist in your search. The Lake Erie Islands is an extremely diverse area which makes it essential to have the support and guidance of a local real estate market expert. Our preferred agents are qualified to handle all aspects of buying and selling real estate, to make the purchase or sale of your new Put-in-Bay home a seamless transaction.

Homes for sale on Put-in-Bay do tend to sell fast. Here is a rundown of what to expect when looking to buying some leeward ln real estate.

What the Market Looks Like

Average Home For Sale

Island Club Community

Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456 (Ottawa County)

3 BR, 2.0 BA, 1100 sq ft, 0.250 acre(s)


These homes have three or four bedrooms and two baths with sleeping for up to eight to ten guests. Most have been recently updated. Guests enter through the rear entry door with a convenient coded electronic door lock. Each has an eat-in kitchen, dining room, and living room. The living room features a television with Cable and Wifi service. The onsite driveway can accommodate up to two regular size vehicles. A typical lot sizes are roughly 1/10th of an acre. Sqft differs from each unit so be sure to ask your realtor. 

Consider lakefront, or Lakeview, island real estate with the Put-in-Bay Condos. Located on 1230 Tri-Motor Drive, the facility completed its new construction in 2016 adding over 20 new listings to the market.

How to get in touch

For those interested in homes for sale at the Island Club or Put-in-Bay Condos contact Paul Jeris at 216-898-9951.  

Other listings on Put-in-Bay/South Bass Island would be done through Bolte Real Estate listings. For Bolte Real Estate listings and MLS listings please call Corky Mcilrath at 419-431-4478.

For other general questions, you can call our Put-in-Bay lodging team at 216-898-9951. Property types vary from single-family homes, townhomes, west shore condos, and more. Don’t be afraid to call!