Looking for a familiar bite while on the go around Put-in-Bay? Don’t want to spend an arm and leg at a sit-down Put-in-Bay restaurant for lunch? Look no further, nestled in the Commodore Resort lobby you’ll find Subway. One of America”s favorite dining option is located in the heart of Put-in-Bay and offers a variety of budget-friendly sandwiches, freshest salads, and breakfast fare.

Budget-Friendly, On-the-Go

Subway is known for its fresh-baked bread and daily sandwich promotions, which is the perfect place to pitstop for some great food while vacationing on the go or on a budget. They are known for their value, consistency, and quality. If you’re looking to splurge for attractions or maybe a big dinner, Subway is a great alternative to saving you a few bucks towards that big meal later. Get a classic Italian sandwich or delicious meatball sub in no time here. It also offer a variety of chips, cookies, and drinks to make your on-the-go meal complete. 

Planning a large event, or have a hungry group to feed during your stay? Subway has you covered and offers catering. Take your Bachelor and bachelorette parties out on the town and then return to the MIST Pool Tiki Bar. Order a party sub for everyone to nibble on as they relax poolside while sipping on a margarita for Caribbean feel. Or if you are looking for outdoor seating walk across the to Derivera Park and enjoy the view of Put-in-Bay Harbor. Anglers and kayakers can even opt for a prepared box lunch that is easy to pack away for their day out on Lake Erie. There’s no reason to go hungry when enjoying all the great attractions Put-in-Bay has to offer!

Once you have finished your sandwich Put-in-Bay, also known as South Bass Island, provides many attractions a short distance away. Take a taxi to Perry’s Cave or drop in to the Village Bakery. Stop by Dairy Isle and get some ice cream for dessert or walk the Boardwalk on Bayview Ave and check out all the diners including Upper Deck. Even Reel Bar, Mossbacks, The Keys, and Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery is a short walk away!

The best perk about Subway in Put-in-Bay, Ohio is they keep the lights on throughout the wee hours of the night to serve the late-night crowd. Those post-drink munchies are bound to happen at Put-in-Bay! Subway can fill the gaps with a quick bite of a late-night delicious sandwich, wrap, or salad.

Eat Fresh!

  • High value, low-cost meals, great vibes
  • Daily sandwich specials
  • Open late for the night owls
  • Convenient downtown location
  • Available for catering

Located behind Mr. Ed’s Bar and Cameo Pizza at the Commodore Resort you’ll find the beloved sandwich eatery. Positioned perfectly downtown Put-in-Bay, Subway is within walking distances of many bars with live entertainment including the Boathouse Bar and Frosty Bar. The Sign will be in front of Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille on Delaware Ave and all you have to do is follow the alley to the familiar green, yellow, and white signage. You can find an alternative entrance by heading north turning right off of Catawba Ave onto the side street across from Hooligans. Stop into Subway on Put-in-Bay, Ohio to eat fresh today! 

The newly renovated Commodore Resort Hotel is one of the island’s most popular hot spots. Here, you will find a variety of rooms which include: king jacuzzi suites, eight-person suites, and the traditional two double bed standard rooms and a whole LOT OF FUN! Make sure to check out all the Commodore Resort has to offer on our lodging resource page and book today!


Joanna S: My family and I were staying at Put-in-Bay Resort for five days last summer. I have six children so keeping everyone fed is not cheap. We tried Chicken Patio and enjoyed it but my oldest was sick of grilled chicken by the third day. Pasquale’s Cafe was also family favorite but that is more of a breakfast place. We also liked Joe’s Bar( great cuban sandwich) but it was to far away from the hotel. Thankfully( for my husbands wallet sake) we found Subway. If you do not want to spend $31 on appetizers, $54 on a Alaskan king crab entrée, or $26 on lobster bisque, this the place to go.

Clay K: The Lake Erie Perch or Walleye on the island is amazing but when you need something quick and easy, this is the place to go.



272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, USA

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.