No vacation is ever complete without bringing home something sweet! While you’re out in Put-in-Bay there is one place that is certain to satisfy the sweet tooth and that is The Put-in-Bay Candy Bar. Willy Wonka’s got nothing on this well-stocked arsenal of sweetness. The Candy Bar is overflowing with a wide variety of candy options for every taste bud you can imagine.

The Candy Bar Location

Conveniently located in the center of downtown Put-in-Bay, the Candy Bar is prepared to cater to your every dessert need. The list of sweets available is longer than the Earth’s waistline so let’s highlight some of their favorites. Just for starters, they offer decadent varieties of fudge, chewy taffy, mouth-watering chocolates, and fun novelty candy. If you’re looking for a cold treat, look no further, because their ice cream is to die for. Can you believe it? Aside from their massive collection of candy, The Candy Bar also has an ice cream shop. Here, they sell an endless selection of flavored ice cream, shakes, sundaes, etc. They also have the option to enjoy your ice cream creation outdoors on their beautiful patio area. They also offer a great selection of candies from days gone by. There is no better gift than a nostalgic sweet memory from childhood.

Tasty Confections at The Candy Bar:

  • Original Bay Fudge
  • Gourmet Ice Cream
  • Cookies
  • Taffy
  • Chocolate Covered Bacon
  • Old Fashioned Milk Shakes

Grab dinner at one of the countless local PIB restaurants nearby and then make your way to The Candy Bar for dessert. Less than a block from The Put-in-Bay Candy Bar, Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille is a local Put-in-Bay hangout. Enjoy one of their signature oversized sandwiches, homemade soups, and/or other daily specials. They even offer live entertainment on the main floor nightly.

Bring your childhood dreams to life and go wild at The Candy Bar! Fill your tummy with whatever you fancy and throw caution to the wind. After you partake on your favorite sweets, remember to grab a sweet for your favorite people. They deserve a sweet reminder of how much you missed them during your Put-In-Bay vacation!


Joe G: “My three-year-old daughter loved this store. The employees were very kind and patient with her. The fudge is great here, but don’t miss the chocolate section either, I highly recommend the chocolate-covered bacon!! They also have lots of prepackaged candy, it’s a great place to take little ones.”

Wanda T: “Amazing as usual. I visit every time I’m on the island. They have a nice selection of candy that I ate as a kid as well as delicious chocolate treats that are fresh and yummy. I usually get fudge, but this time I had the chocolate covered strawberries and white chocolate covered pretzels! Yum!”

Donny B: “What a fun place for kids (and us too!). They have a huge selection of great products. The fudge is AMAZING. Old candies you thought were lost in the past?! They still have them! The staff is great as well.”

Brain C: “Great selection of candies, both traditional and exotic. From Gummy Worms to suckers with actual insects inside, something for everyone. Also a small selection of treats made on-premises.”




198 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA