Food, fun and entertainment are the name of the game at Frosty’s, a South Bass Island staple. This island bar favorite has been serving up ice cold beers, appetizers, cheesy pizza and tons of entertainment for 60 years. With great food options for every meal of the day and drink options for all manners of thirst, Frosty Bar is the best spot to stop in during a visit to the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay. Located next door Pasquale’s Cafe an across the street from Derivera Park. 

No Matter the Meal, Frosty Bar is the Place

In the morning, Frosty Bar serves up hearty breakfast to get your day going right — stop in for eggs cooked to order, breakfast sandwiches, pancakes or one of our great daily breakfast specials. After you spend time checking out the attractions of Put-in-Bay, take a lunch break and dig into Frosty’s legendary pizza. Thick crust is piled high with cheese and toppings. If pizza isn’t your thing, grab a specialty sandwich — especially the Italian Sub, Gyro or Buffalo Ranch Chicken. Hankerin’ for a cold one? They don’t get much colder than at Frosty’s, where your beer is served in an ice cold mug.

Dinner with the family can be budget-friendly at Frosty Bar, where the Family Meal will feed everyone — one low price gets guests a large pizza, family salad, breadsticks and four sodas. You can’t beat this deal anywhere on the island!

Frosty Bar Features

  • Family-friendly Dining Options
  • DJ Entertainment on Weekends
  • Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner Served
  • Big Man’s Burrito Stand on Property
  • Beer Served in Ice-Cold Mug

Frosty Bar is a staple to island visitors. Conveniently located in downtown and close to the Jet Express ferry and, Frosty Bar is an easy and fun place to dip into for a nice bite to eat. Take a break from the fun and excitement on the island with a visit to Frosty’s. They also have a super fun gift shop full of Frosty and Put-in-Bay themed goodies!

Frosty Bar Hours

Monday-Thursday from 11 AM to 7 PM

Friday from 11 AM to 1 AM

Saturday from 7 AM to 1 AM

Sunday from 7 AM to 7 PM

Come check out Frosty’s famous breakfast from 7 AM to 11 AM on Saturday and Sunday!

ADDRESS: 252 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456


Josh S: “If you’re not into the night life, this is still a great place to go to for breakfast. I think it’s the best breakfast in town. there is a server there named Derek. If you need info on anything going on in Put In Bay, just ask him. He has been here for a long time and he will take the time to share his knowledge with you.”

Karrie P: “We ate breakfast on a Sunday. We were seated quickly and our waitress was great. Our food was done fast and everything was good. Bought a couple shirts and the man selling them was helpful about showing us the shirts and helping to find a size. Always a good spot to stop.”

Mackenzie D: “Best bar & restaurant on the island, hands down!! Perfect for all 3 meals, Breakfast – amazing service & blueberry pancakes! Lunch – enjoy a walking taco out on the back patio, while watching a live band. Dinner – get that pepperoni pizza, and enjoy a cold one while watching a live band or sports game inside!!”


You might want to stay an extra day with all the Put-in-Bay attractions! There is plenty to do on the island for all ages so check out our lodging options at our Put-in-Bay resort, hotels, condo, and rentals. The sooner you book, the sooner you can get on a Put-in-Bay ferry!

Other Put-in-Bay Restaurants and Bars

Put-in-Bay, Ohio provides many great dining options. This includes the island favorite Upperdeck located on the Boardwalk. Try their walleye or famous lobster bisque. With plenty of outdoor seating, enjoy the the view enjoy of the Lake Erie Islands with your meal. You can not mention the best restaurants on the island without mentioning the Goat Soup & Whiskey. Order a German beer and relax in their Biergarten!

Looking for the best bars on the island? Start off a the tiki bar Mojito Bay. This Caribbean themed bar is the ideal place to order a margarita and enjoy the live music. Looking for the most popular bar spot on the island? Than Delaware Ave is where you need to be. There you will find Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille, Frostys, and the Round House Bar. All of these bars host live entertainment. You will also find multiple bars just a short walk away on Catawba Avenue. This includes  the Reel Bar, the Irish pub Hooligans, Fishbowl, and Mossbacks. If you are looking for a true island experience than the Put-in-Bay bars are great place to start.


252 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.