Frosty Gifts is the premier headquarters for all of your dedicated Frosty Bar gear. There is literally something for everyone at Frosty’s. Choose from an eclectic selection of food options, such as piping hot pizza, subs, gyros, or fun breakfast specialties like Billy’s Banana Pancakes. Make sure you grab an ice cold beer to wash down your meal and take a stroll outback to Big Man’s Burrito Stand located in the rear of the property.

This is the perfect location for every type of appetite in your group. With that said, if you’d prefer to eat on the go or maybe from the comfort of your own rental home or hotel room, order to-go. Online ordering is now available or feel free to call Frosty Bar directly to place your order. Drink from your ice cold ‘frosty’ mug, sit in their patio area, and eat delicious food. Then head to Frosty Gifts to show your adoration for all things Frosty.

Outdoor Fun at Frosty’s

  • The Backyard at Frosty’s Bar
  • Big Man’s Burrito Stand
  • Live Entertainment

Conveniently Located Shopping

Hop on a bicycle, moped, or golf cart and ride the downtown Delaware Avenue strip. There are Put-in-Bay attractions and shops to choose from, such as Cruisin Tunes for all of your music needs. Stop by the Candy Bar and indulge in mountains of sweet treats like ice cream, fudge, cookies, and all sorts of nostalgic candy. If you’re looking for that perfect vacation hat, bathing suit, or beach bag head over to Lovella Fashion Apparel. All of these great shops and more are within a stone’s throw from the ever-so-popular Delaware Avenue strip.

No matter which shop you plan to visit first, you will want to see them all and browse their offerings. Each Put-in-Bay store has a specialty that stands out. Del Sol, for example, has more than 600 items that transform color when exposed to sunlight! Once removed from the sunlight, they return back to their original color. The Great Lakes Tobacconist is also another example of a Put-in-Bay specialty. Here, you will find Put-in-Bay inspired smokes and tobaccos, hand rolled by tobacco artisans in the Dominican Republic.


Mackenzie D: “Best bar & restaurant on the island, hands down!! Perfect for all 3 meals, Breakfast – amazing service & blueberry pancakes! Lunch – enjoy a walking taco out on the back patio, while watching a live band. Dinner – get that pepperoni pizza, and enjoy a cold one while watching a live band or sports game inside!!”

Josh S: “If you’re not into the night life, this is still a great place to go to for breakfast. I think it’s the best breakfast in town. there is a server there named Derek. If you need info on anything going on in Put In Bay, just ask him. He has been here for a long time and he will take the time to share his knowledge with you.”

Karrie P: “We ate breakfast on a Sunday. We were seated quickly and our waitress was great. Our food was done fast and everything was good. Bought a couple shirts and the man selling them was helpful about showing us the shirts and helping to find a size. Always a good spot to stop.”

Shop until you drop, but preferably nearby in a hotel room or rental home! Find The Best Put-in-Bay Resort, Hotels, Rentals, And Condos Here. Visit our lodging page and BOOK Now! The sooner you book, the sooner you can get on a Put-in-Bay ferry!

252 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA